These Superstar Athletes Never Won The Big Game

Jim Kelly Went To Four Straight Super Bowls And Lost Them All

jim kelly.jpg

Photo Credit: Rick Stewart /Allsport via Getty Images

Try as he might, Jim Kelly never won a Super Bowl. You’d think he’d accidentally win one after four straight appearances. Unfortunately, the accidents Kelly needed to happen were never his favor. During his first Super Bowl, Bills kicker Scott Norwood missed a chip-shot field that would have won the game.

Two Super Bowls later Kelly’s Bills were blown out by the Troy Aikman led Cowboys 52-17! In his fourth and final February appearance, Kelly was defeated by Aikman again, this time by a more respectable score of 30-13. Respectable here is a relative term, of course.